pratitya samutpada – multiple causation

Jo Etta has a post on the Change for Missouri blog that in part asks whether the poor are to blame for their plight. The answer is, of course, “pratitya samutpada“, or multiple causation. Like nearly all human phenomena, no human situation has merely one cause. The question is in the percentages.

Any situation, whether poverty or teenage pregnancy, can be a combination of several factors such as other people having power over us, or the way the social or political system is set up which may limit our own choices, or perhaps our own unwise decisions may contribute (just how does a teenager develop wisdom anyway?), and usually will be a combination of all.

For instance, a young girl may get pregnant because a guy is able to leverage a tiny difference in power, such as a tiny five ounce metal object called a knife held to her throat. Or she may get pregnant and stay that way because society requires parental notification and so permits the guy who impregnated her (her father) to decide whether or not she is allowed to have an abortion. Or she may passively allow herself to get and stay pregnant because if she has a baby, then she will have at least someone in her life who can’t just use her and abandon her. Or all three can be true at the same time. That’s how multiple causation works.

Some people will say that if her own choices contributed even one percent for the situation, then she is totally responsible for the results. Others will say otherwise.

Same with poverty. Some person or group may start a business that undercuts prices and kills off all nearby businesses, and then uses its near monopoly to impoverish the entire community. Or our legislature may structure the legal system so that the rich can pass their wealth down to their descendents with no taxes, while the poor and middle class are required to give all their accumulated saving to hospitals or nursing homes as they lay dying, so their descendents are left with no inheritance at all and thus at a severe disadvantage. Or the poor may be that way because they made the unwise decision to fail to engage in the unethical business practices that allowed the wealthy to get that way.

See? Multiple causation. So just who is responsible when the weak get screwed by the strong?

Advertisements

3 Responses to pratitya samutpada – multiple causation

  1. Jo Etta says:

    In talking about multiple causation for poverty, I would have included screwing around in school and being careless about showing up for work on time or taking too many sick days. The “Being Poor” posting I quoted implies those problems when it said: “Being poor is having to live with choices you didn’t know you made when you were 14 years old.” I’m not being hard-nosed, but I am trying to be realistic and balanced. I don’t excuse the immorality of corporate behavior or the unwillingness of government to create conditions where people can thrive. Those are the sins of wealth and power that I want progressive politics to ameliorate. I just believe in personal responsibility as well. And, as I said in my posting, I think most poor people are responsible. They work at hard jobs for little pay.

  2. […] yesterday’s post on “Being Poor”, had his own comments to make at his blog site Numen Notes. Posted January 12, 2007 by Jo Etta in Blog with 0 […]

  3. numen says:

    The problem is that poor people have to be *much* more responsible than rich people.

    If a poor teenage girl makes a single mistake, such as one individual act of unprotected sex, her future may well be permanently destroyed, But if a George Bush makes dozens of enormous mistakesm he can recover and even become President.

    Personal responsibility has very different meanings for the rich and the poor,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: